Jay (b. 1935) played in the majors from 1953 (at the age of 17) to 1955 and 1957 to 1966 for the Braves and Reds. He had a record of 99-91 with 999 strike outs and a 3.77 ERA. He won 21 games twice in his career (1961 and 1962). He finished 5th in the NL MVP race in 1961 and was an All Star twice that season.
I mailed to Jay on January 17 and got the cards back on January 26, for a 9-day TAT. I paid his fee of $5/card.